Cape May Bagel & Cold Brew

Creating the perfect combo for our community! Traditional New York style bagels and smooth, refreshing cold brew. What could be better?

Order Now

Cal's Pals Paddle for Preemies

Join us for Cal’s Pals Paddle for Preemies, a 120-mile paddle from Cape May to Sandy Hook, NJ, on July 19–20, 2025. This inspiring event raises funds to support families with children in the NICU and PICU. Be part of a meaningful journey along the Jersey Shore and help make a difference.

Learn More & Sign Up

Our Products

Select products below for next day delivery or pickup.

Bagels

Plain

$9/4 Pack

$13/Half Dozen
•
$25/Dozen
Everything

$9/4 Pack

$13/Half Dozen
•
$25/Dozen
Cinnamon Sugar

$9/4 Pack

$13/Half Dozen
•
$25/Dozen
Black Sesame & Sea Salt

$9/4 Pack

$13/Half Dozen
•
$25/Dozen
Cheddar Jalapeño

$9/4 Pack

$13/Half Dozen
•
$25/Dozen
Cinnamon Raisin

$9/4 Pack

$13/Half Dozen
•
$25/Dozen
Sesame

$9/4 Pack

$13/Half Dozen
•
$25/Dozen
Whole Wheat

$9/4 Pack

$13/Half Dozen
•
$25/Dozen
Whole Wheat Everything

$9/4 Pack

$13/Half Dozen
•
$25/Dozen
Pretzel

$12/4 Pack

$15/Half Dozen
•
$30/Dozen
Bialy

$12/4 Pack

$15/Half Dozen
•
$30/Dozen

Spreads

Plain Cream Cheese

$5/8oz
Flavored Cream Cheese

$6.50/8oz
Smoked Nova Cream Cheese

$7.50/8oz
Tuna Salad

$10/8oz
Chicken Salad

$10/8oz
Whitefish Salad

$10/8oz
Egg Salad

$10/8oz

Coffee

Cold Brew Concentrate

$20/32oz

Dilute with water.
Stir, Sip, Enjoy.
’76 Espresso

$15.50/12oz

Roast: Dark
Schuylkill Select

$15.50/12oz

Roast: Medium
Colombia Tolima

$18/12oz

Roast: Medium

Questions? Head over to our contact page

hand holding a cold brew coffee with the ocean in the background

Who Is Cape May Bagel & Cold Brew?

We are Aaron and Julie, husband and wife, committed to bringing fresh bagels and delicious cold brew to our community! All of our bagels are hand rolled, made with love and from scratch, using unbleached and unbromated flour without preservatives.

Learn More